Hi,
“Neither growing old nor accumulating life experiences is sufficient for growing wise.” - Current Opinion in Psychology journal.
“Awareness, not age, leads to wisdom.” - Publius Syrus
There’s around 2000 years of time between the utterances of these two sentences.
I’ve long held the implicit assumption that greater experience affords greater competence and wisdom.
From primary school through postgraduate medical training, there is a sense of a determined path, a climbing of the ladder, and steps closer to mastery.
I’ve always valued competence, as it’s the answer to many practical problems; “ the building stands, the car now runs, the lights are on”.
But I’ve increasingly come to see that competence, although a pre-requisite, is not sufficient. A psychopath may be the most competent person in the room.
The road through medical school and training toward competence has always been inherently hierarchical. The lecturers and consultants are gatekeepers of knowledge, skills and opportunities, and there is a clear pathway forward (medical student → foundation doctor → trainee → etc etc).
So it seems self-evident that those above in this hierarchy are more knowledgable, capable, and wise.
Why would I ask more senior colleagues for clinical advice otherwise? Why would the medical students listen to me teaching? (maybe they have no choice...)
More than ten years of medical school and training have ingrained this sense of ‘those above’ being wiser. Generally, this holds true.
But by extension, I may subconsciously sense that my ‘wiser self’ is somewhere in the distance, over the horizon; if just for more time, training, repetition, exams, courses, assessments, I will eventually get there.
With this, comes the persistent sense that I have never ‘arrived’.
But progression through training gives peeks through the cracks. You see newspaper scandals involving clinicians, mistakes made, or instances of questionable behaviour that undermine the assumption that wisdom is somewhere higher up the ladder.
“Awareness, not age, leads to wisdom.”
Receding on the approach like a mirage, wisdom doesn’t come from the passing of time.
We’ve seen enough evidence across our political, social and other institutions to know that the top of the hierarchy by no means guarantees wisdom. It’s the recognised phenomenon that most adults are just winging it and no one really has it figured out.
Medicine has taught me the following: pay attention, maintain a degree of scepticism, don’t ignore your instinct, hold firm beliefs loosely, and maybe it’s possible to be a little wiser in the here and now. |